7 Best Training Collars For Stubborn Dogs In 2023 (Reviewed)

This post contains affiliate links, we'll earn compensation if you make a purchase using them at no additional cost to you  😊

A training collar for uncooperative dogs can help you control undesirable behaviors if you have a new dog or have a stubborn four-legged family member. 

Unfortunately, a lack of discipline or socialization results in most dogs developing problematic traits and habits. Although utilizing a training collar requires more effort and time, it is one of the best strategies to curb bad behavior. 

You can have a contented and well-mannered pet by supporting them with consistent positive reinforcement with these training collars, which also function as bark collar for puppies and grown-up dogs.

Hence, I’ve compiled a list of the top training collars for stubborn dogs, whether you’re beginning with training with a new dog or attempting to teach an old dog a new trick.

So, let’s check each of the collars individually and in detail.

7 Best Training Collars For Stubborn Dogs In A Nutshell

Here is a table representing our 7 picks of best training collars that are durable and effective for stubborn dogs. Here you go:

RankBest Training Collar For Stubborn DogsBest For? (Special Feature)Price
1. SportDOG Brand 425X (Remote)Best Overall$119.95
2.PatPet Training Collar.Best to control Barking$69.99
3.Mini Educator ET-300 (Remote).Best for two dogs at a time$199.99
4.PetSPY P620.Best as per People’s choice$69.99
5.Garmin Sport Pro.Best for hunting dogs$249.99
6.Bousnic dog shock collarBest for a sleek design$57.39
7. IPETS PET 618Best for long-lasting battery$29.99

Whether you are training a new dog from basic to advanced commands or teaching your existing dog a few new tricks, the collars mentioned below are Do-It-All collars, just like a bark collar for puppies.

So, now that you have previewed the best training collars for stubborn dogs above, I will discuss them in detail, featuring the collar’s technical specifications, pros, cons, and prices. 

Let’s get into it!

1. SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Training Collar

Best Training Collars For Stubborn Dogs  - Overview
Source– Amazon
  • Waterproof Rating: IP67
  • Training Modes: Static, Vibe, And Tone
  • Suitable Dog Weight: 8 lbs and above
  • Range: 500 Yards

The SportDog brand has been made at the top of this list because of its ability to stop aggressive behavior and nuisance barking or train a dog efficiently. 

It also provides seven levels of stimulation, which help you to modify the process and get the results you desire in a short duration.

The thing is, stubborn dogs think with their own mind rather than just depending on their owner

Plus, with this collar’s durability and waterproofing, the collar can endure any condition that might occur naturally.

Moreover, even though it is a bit expensive, it is worth every penny.


  • The training collar is easy to use.
  • It can be used for multiple dogs to train them simultaneously.
  • The lithium-ion batteries are effective and charge up fast.


  • The collar is a bit expensive.

2. PatPet Dog Training Collar

PatPet Dog Training Collar
Source– Amazon
  • Waterproof Rating: IPX5 (Remote) & IPX7 (Collar)
  • Training Modes: Beep, Vibration, and Static
  • Suitable Dog Weight: 10 to 140 lbs
  • Range: 3000 Ft.

Although a dog may use barking as a beneficial alert mechanism for outsiders or to interact with other dogs, it can also result in disruptive behavior if it is constant. 

The PATPET dog training collar offers dog owners a cost-effective way to put an end to annoying barking and bad behavior.

You can select the stimulation technique that’s effective for both you and your dog using the three training modes. 

Additionally, you can select your favorite color to customize the training collar for your dog. It’s not necessary for obedience training to be tiresome.


  • It has three modes to correct your dog’s behavior.
  • It is user-friendly.
  • It’s affordable.
  • The collar is available in a wide range of colors.


  • It might not work that effectively if used on dogs with thicker fur.

3. Mini Educator ET-300 Remote Training Collar

Mini Educator ET-300 Remote
Source– Amazon
  • Waterproof Rating: 
  • Training Modes: Tone and Vibration
  • Suitable Dog Weight: 5 lbs and above
  • Range:½ Miles

This stopwatch-looking remote device is considered the best in the market because of its 100 levels of static stimulation-releasing ability, vibrations, and tone.

You can choose the stimulation level per your dog’s stubbornness and temperament. Plus, the collar has an additional 60 levels as a booster if the dog is distracted frequently. 

It has a range of ½ mile and is suitable for field training sessions with your dog. You can train 2 -dogs simultaneously. 


  • It has an additional 60 levels to give a boost.
  • It comes with rechargeable batteries.
  • You can train about 3 dogs simultaneously with this collar.
  • It comes with a 1-year warranty.


  • The collar doesn’t expand more than 22 inches.

4. PetSPY P620 Dog Training Shock Collar

PetSPY P620 Dog Training
Source– Amazon
  • Waterproof Rating: Yes (rating not available)
  • Training Modes: Tone, Vibration, and Shock.
  • Suitable Dog Weight: 10 to 140 lbs
  • Range: 650 Yards

This versatile training collar has powerful features and was specially created to correct a dog’s wrong behavior. It has multiple correction options, including the beep, vibration, and shock. 

PetSPY P620 fits dogs from 10 to 140 lbs and has a 650-yard range to teach a dog the recall command.

With 16 adjustable shock levels that help you train your dog to discipline your dogs humanely. Also, you can train your dog for extra hours because of its long-lasting battery without charging it for several days.

Moreover, with its versatile feature package, it is indeed a choice for many dog trainers and dog parents worldwide.


  • This training collar helps you to control excessive barking and anger issues humanely.
  • Professionals and amateurs can both use this collar efficiently.
  • The collar is made of durable and premium materials.


  • The neck strap is longer and doesn’t fit small dogs easily.

5. Garmin Sport Pro Dog Training Collar

Garmin Sport Pro Dog
Source– Amazon
  • Waterproof Rating: IPX7
  • Training Modes: Continuous and momentary stimulation, Vibration, and tone.
  • Suitable Dog Weight: Information not available.
  • Range: 1300 Ft.

If you enjoy being outside, you’ve probably heard of Garmin. 

In addition to producing top-notch equipment for backcountry exploration, they also produce the greatest shock collar for hunting dogs. 

A special link is formed between you and your dog due to the experiences you have together while scavenging outdoors. 

However, it’s essential to train your dog before going out into the field, and the easiest way to do that is by using a training collar. 

With hunters and their cherished best buddies in mind, the Garmin Sport Pro was created. The 1,300-foot range of the small and light design is evidence of that. 

The range of most training collars is 500 feet, while the Garmin Sport Pro provides an additional range.


  • The collar device is lightweight as well as compact in size.
  • This system has ten stimulation levels.
  • It comes in customizable accessories and color options.
  • The device is durable and can be efficiently used in the field.


  • Dogs under 8 lbs are not suitable for this collar.

6. Bousnic Dog Shock Collar

 Bousnic Dog Shock Collar
Source– Amazon
  • Waterproof Rating: IPx7
  • Training Modes: Beep, Vibration, and safe shock.
  • Suitable Dog Weight: 8 to 120 lbs.
  • Range: 1000 ft.

Another useful collar that will help in training your dog and can also be one of the best bark collars for puppies is the Bousnic Dog Shock Collar, which has three training modes: beep, vibration, and safe shock. 

The ergonomic layout of the collar and remote is what really stands out to me about this collar. The collar is incredibly minimalistic and light, making it perfect for dogs of various sizes. 

Additionally, nylon, which is comfortable and breathable for dogs, was used to make the item.

Since the remote is silicone-coated, it is simple to handle and use.,

Plus, it features a second channel, allowing you to access it simultaneously. I might find this incredibly helpful because I have two


  • The Bousnic dog shock training collar has a sleek and lightweight design.
  • There are only black and white color options for this collar.


  • There are only black and white color options for this collar.

7. IPETS PET618 Dog Training Shock Collar

IPETS PET618 Dog Training Shock Collar
Source– Amazon
  • Waterproof Rating: Waterproof (No IP rating available).
  • Training Modes: Tone, Vibration, and Static shock.
  • Suitable Dog Weight: 15 lbs and above.
  • Range: 2600 Ft.

When you use it to its full potential, the 100% waterproof collar becomes the show’s star.  Plus, the IPET collar can withstand all types of weather while keeping your puppy calm.

The collar functions based on Tone, vibrations, and safe shock and has a rechargeable battery. Moreover, you can train your dog from a distance within the 2600ft range. 

The collar allows faster corrections by providing stimulation buttons instead of multiple extra buttons. It has adjustable intensity, allowing you to manage the intensity levels of all the training modes.

Furthermore, the two-plug charger lets you charge the transmitter and the collar receiver at the same time. 

This collar efficiently offers the overall requirements of a dog training collar to manage your stubborn dog.


  • The pairing process with this collar is easy and straightforward.
  • It has contact points made of plastic.
  • The collar has a long-lasting battery.
  • The IPET PET618 can work efficiently, even with some charging.


  • It has a shorter range than its competitor collars in the same price range.

How to Choose The Best Training Collar For Your Dog? 

Even if all the dog training collars, puppy bark collars, or bark collars for 3 old puppy look similar to you, there are many important differences among training collars.

The best suitable training collar entirely depends on your and your dog’s requirements while training to fulfill the training goals. Some training collars also function as a bark collar for puppies and large dogs.

Plus, there are a few parameters you need to go through while buying a training collar for your dog.

1. Your Dog’s safety

A responsible dog parent would only want to use the training collar to correct a certain dog behavior by training them with a dog collar. 

Hence, be sure to use a training collar with additional features like tone/ sound and vibration instead of a traditional shock collar. 

2. Training Goals

Many training collars function for different purposes. Some dog owners need training collars for yard training, some only need a bark collar, or some might need it to train a working duty dog or a hunting dog. 

Therefore, make sure to choose an option suitable for your training goals.

3. Your Dog’s Size and Temperament

If the collar you bought for your dog doesn’t fit perfectly, the collar will not work effectively. Some collars can be adjusted and fit dogs from large to small. 

However, some collars come in specific sizes. Hence, be sure to buy a collar suitable for your dog’s neck size and measure your dog’s neck size with the one or two-finger rule.

4. Range Requirements

The Range requirements of each dog owner depend on how much freedom of space they want to offer to their dogs. 

Many times, a ½ mile range or 1 mile is enough for dog owners. However, if they are you are in doubt, get a collar with a higher range. The reason is, that less space range would become a problem for you and your dog to have the freedom to train and play.

5. Speed and Reliability

The stimulation should be instant for a training collar to properly correct the dog’s behavior and communicate at the right moment with your dog.

Some cheap dog collars deliver unreliable connections and end up being ineffective while training your dog. That’s why choosing a training collar with guaranteed reliability is the best option to choose.

Useful Links:

Final Verdict: Best Training Collars For Stubborn Dogs In 2023:

Your best friend is your dog, and maintaining that dog is possible with the best training collar for stubborn dogs listed above. 

A firm foundation of teaching that evolves into respect and mutual trust is the most effective method to provide them with a satisfying and happy long life. 

The SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Training Collar, our top overall recommendation, provides a superb blend of range, training modes, and durability to handle even the most recalcitrant behavior. 

A dependable and long-lasting training collar is able to make all the difference in giving your dog a secure, joyful, and sound life.


Which collar type do dog trainers usually use to train dogs?

Dog trainers usually use Martingale collars to train dogs that tighten undeAr pressure but not in a way that will pressure your dog’s neck like a pong collar.

Do shock training collars for dogs really work on stubborn dogs?

As shock training collars have multiple other options to train your dog humanely, you can correct your dog whenever it behaves wrongly. Therefore, shock training collar for dogs turns out to be effective for stubborn dogs as well.

Why do people opt for e-collars for training over harnesses or normal neck collars for dogs?

E-collars are designed to provide instantly correction features, which also leads to a dog learning good behavior faster than with normal harnesses and neck collars for dogs. That’s why people opt for e-collars more than regular collars.

Is a bark collar safe for puppies?

A bark collar or training collar is safe for the puppy as long as your puppy is six months or above, as vets and dog experts around the world don’t recommend using it for too young pups.

Are bark collars bad for puppies?

As mentioned earlier, bark collars can be used for puppies as long as the puppy is six months or older to avoid harming your dog’s limbs and fragile muscle tissues. 

Is there a bark collar for a 3-month-old puppy?

Many collars in the market claim to be useful for dogs as young as three months,  but no primarily designed bark collars for 3-month-old puppy.

About The Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *