Are Vibration Collars Humane? (Unveiling The Truth)

This post contains affiliate links, we'll earn compensation if you make a purchase using them at no additional cost to you  😊

Due to their similar functioning as shock or bark collars, vibration collars are often mistaken as harmful. There is a lot of confusion between dog parents worldwide about using vibration collars. But a question that troubles dog parents is, ‘Are vibration collars humane?’

I have used vibration collars with my dogs at home and the dog shelter I was volunteering for, and it turned out helpful for me. 

So, before listening to rumors surrounding vibration collars, check out the clarification below to let go of the misconceptions about the tool.

Let’s take a look!

Key Takeaways From This Article

  • Dog vibration collars are humane and help you correct your dog’s behavior and stop excessive barking.
  • Vibration collars are the best way to communicate with deaf dogs and train them with obedience commands.
  • Even though vibration collars are harmless, they might trigger fear and anxiety in fragile or small dogs. Therefore, you must use them correctly, as mentioned below.
  • Before getting a vibration collar, be sure to check the following factors – Weatherproof and waterproof, Intensity level settings, Durability, Multiple training modes, The right size for your dog’s neck, and Suitable for your dog’s weight.
  • Vibration collars are always a better and safer option than shock collars.
  • Teaching your dog to socialize and using shock collars are the two alternatives to vibration collars.

Bonus: Check out the the best-vibrating collars in the market by simply clicking here.

Are Vibration Collars Humane?
Source: amazon.com

Are Vibration Collars Humane Or Harmful?

Dog vibration collars are humane and not harmful at all. It only creates a small, gentle buzz-like sensation around your dog’s neck where it is placed. 

It helps you to give commands to your dog to stop barking, making it the ultimate solution to change your dog’s wrong behavior.

So, if you’re wondering are vibration collars safe for dogs, you have nothing to worry about.

Vibrating dog collars were originally made as a solution for deaf dogs to communicate with them. Dog owners and trainers used it for training deaf dogs with new commands. 

However, nowadays, these vibrating dog collars are used as bark collars and training collars for all dogs. 

If you’re still worried about the vibrations, you should know that in modern vibration collars, you will find intensity levels to adjust the vibration sensations.

If your dog is sensitive, you can keep the vibration levels low and keep them higher if your dog is strong and can tolerate extra sensations.

Most dog owners who are well-experienced with training their own dogs also recommend using dog collars to train dogs with positive reinforcement. For extra positivity, you can add your dog’s favorite treats and toys as a reward when your dog listens to you.

Dog Vibration Collar Recommendations

If you decide to buy a dog vibration collar for your dog, we have three of the Best Vibrating Collar recommendations for you. 

Technical SpecificationsSportDog Brand 425XPaws Fluoroscopy No-Shock CollarPatPet Training Dog Collar 
Price$154.95$ 72.99$69.99
Training ModesStatic, Vibration, and Tone/Beep/SoundStatic, Vibration, and Tone/Beep/SoundStatic, Vibration, and Tone/Beep/Sound
Dog Weight 8 lbs and over8 to 120 lbs15 to 140 lbs
Water-resistant IP RatingsFully Water-resistant  (No IP certification)IPX7 IPX7 
Battery Life70 hours per charge11 to 15 days per charge30 days per charge

Bonus: These were our top 3 recommendations from our list of Best Vibrating Dog Collars, which you can check out the complete list by clicking here.

Vibration Collar For Deaf Dogs

Dog parents with deaf dogs constantly suffer through the issue of communicating with their dogs. Using a vibration collar to communicate with your dog is the best solution that commands your dog just as you want.

You can start training your dog with a vibration collar with positive reinforcement by offering treats to your dog. Repeat this process multiple times until your dog starts looking at you when you press the remote button. 

Also, a vibration collar on your deaf dog should be used only to get their attention and not to correct their wrong behavior. 

If you keep using the vibration collar simultaneously to get and correct their attention, it will only confuse them.

Vibration Collar For Deaf Dogs
Source: amazon.com

Pros And Cons: Dog Vibration Collars

Vibration collars have tons of benefits, but like everything else in the world, vibrating collars also have some minor drawbacks. 

So, to understand dog vibration collars based on the good and bad, let’s check out the information given below:

Pros

  • A vibration collar allows you to train your dog from a distance.
  • Your dog learns to listen to commands even when the dog is off-leash.
  • Dogs who respond to sounds and voices faster learn commands faster.
  • Alerts you instantly of your dog’s wrong behavior.
  • It’s a safer alternative to train aggressive dogs. 
  • It’s the ultimate solution for the owner and dog to communicate easily.

Cons

  • It can boost anxiety in dogs.
  • Fragile dogs might get scared by the vibrations.
  • It can be harmful to the dog if used with insufficient knowledge.

The Correct Method To Use A Dog Vibration Collar

Training is pretty effective when you incorporate hand gestures and words with the vibration collar. Initially, the tingling sensation released by the vibration collar feels strange to your dog. Hence, you must make your dog understand why the collar releases the shock.

At first, you must let the dog realize that if they are doing something wrong. You follow the steps below to use the vibration collar correctly:

  • Step #1: Ask your dog to come to you, and if your dog walks away from you without obeying your command, press the vibration button.
  • Step #2: Set a couple of hand gestures with the vibration to let the dog let the dog know what he should do. 
  • Step #3: The next time your dog obeys your command of coming to you when you call, give the dog a treat and praise them with a ‘Good Boy/Girl’ complement.
  • Step #4: If your dog ignores lower-intensity vibrations, you can increase the intensity, but only if your dog can tolerate it.

Tips To Choose The Right Dog Vibration Collar

Refer to the following tips to choose the right dog vibration collar for your dog:

The Right Dog Vibration Collar
Source: amazon.com
  • Check if the vibrating dog collar is weatherproof and waterproof.
  • Check if the vibrating collar has intensity level settings.
  • The material of the collar should be durable enough.
  • The collar should have multiple training modes as many modern-day vibrating collars are built with at least three training modes: Beep/Sound, Vibration, and Static Shock.
  • Check if the vibrating collar is the right size for your dog’s neck.
  • Check if the vibrating collar is suitable for your dog’s weight.

Vibration Collar Vs. Shock Collar: Which Is Better?

A vibration collar is the most practical yet safer option for dogs to correct their behavior or train them with new commands. Many dog parents worldwide prefer using vibration collars instead of shock collars due to the safety measures vibration collars come with. 

They offer zero pain and harmful shock and still effectively stop a dog from excessive barking and unwanted behavior.

On the other hand, an e-collar or shock collar employs static electric shock to correct a dog’s behavior. However, if the handler of the shock collar is not properly trained, it may cause harm to the dog with false alarms and shock released at the wrong time.

Nonetheless, if you still decide to get a shock collar for your dog, check my recommendations for safe and the best shock collars to keep your dog away from getting harmed.

Note: Usage of high-intensity levels in both vibration and shock collars should be avoided as much as possible to avoid harming or triggering anxiety in dogs. 

Alternatives To Dog Vibration Collars

As mentioned above, shock collars/e-collars are an alternative to dog vibration collars. However, a vibration collar will always be the safer and better option for dogs than a shock collar. 

Our team at Bring Jackson Home and many dog experts worldwide suggest using a shock collar as the last resort to train or correct a dog’s behavior.

Furthermore, socialization is another option to make your dog stop barking in unwanted situations and at strangers, as they often bark when in fear. 

If dogs frequently start socializing with other humans and animals, they are less likely to bark after encountering a new person or situation.

Related Reads

The Bottom Line: Are vibration collars humane?

There are plenty of training collars on the market, but not all collars have enough safety measures, while vibration collars are considered to be a better option. But are vibration collars humane? 

Many dog parents have asked this question over the years, and we’ve tried to give our honest take on it. You can peacefully use vibration collars, knowing they are safe, humane, and a better alternative than shock collars.

However, use tools like vibrating, shock, and bark collars with complete knowledge and guidance to avoid harming your furry companions.

FAQs

Are vibration collars safe for dogs?

Vibrating collars are humane and safe for your dog if you set the intensity levels lower or per your dog’s tolerance level.

Are vibration collars better than shock collars?

Vibration collars are a better alternative than shock collars in terms of safety and gentleness.

Are vibrating collars effective?

Vibrating collars are a proven and best tool for training and communicating with your dog. So, vibrating collars are effective, according to vibration collar users’ reviews worldwide.

Can you use vibration collars safely in the rain?

Most vibration collars come with water-resistant IP Ratings and are entirely safe to use in the rain. However, check if the vibration collar is waterproof and weatherproof for water and rain.

About The Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *